Wow, what an active and helpful forum....16 responses in less than 12 hours! Thanks for the very specific advice. I got a bunch of useful information:
1. :arrow: Ask about a return policy so that I can try it out and send back if dissatisfied....but check for restocking fee.
From killdeer43: "you need to have that guitar in your OWN hands to make the decision, and the return option will make for a more relaxing test drive"
From Joe: "...still need to feel/hear that guitar in the flesh….hear and feel the guitar"
From fronobalax: "If there is major damage by the carrier do you get a complete refund, a new guitar, or just reimbursed for repair work"
2. :arrow: Be cautious of UPS ground, consider upgrading (from capnjuan
3. :arrow: Try it out
From onewilyfool: "You may ask YOURSELF, why you are buying before trying"
I'm definitely uneasy about buying without touching it. I'd like to try one out but have found no F512 at any Guild dealer within 250 miles of where I live... I played someone else's F512 a while back and liked it better than my current G312. Craigslist has turned up a 1-2 in the past few months but they are either sold right away or priced very close to the price of a new one and have no warranty. So I think I will definitely need a generous return policy with a zero or low restocking fee so I can play it and make sure I'll be happy with it.
4. :arrow: Authorized Guild dealer
From evenkeel: "That the dealer is an authorized Guild dealer" Good idea, I went to Guild site and found the dealer on their authorized dealer list.
5. :arrow: Try Guitars of Montana
From West: "I'd just order from Bing at Guitars of Montana and not worry about it."
I just emailed Bing to ask about some NOS Tacoma Guilds he mentions on their website.
I'm in no giant hurry so if anyone has any other tips, I'd appreciate them! Thanks