I don’t think you’re nuts, I think it’s rational thinking. I’ve gone through a similar exercise recently, where I’ve been downsizing and tweaking the collection accordingly, selling multiple inexpensive ones for upgrades to one or two quality ones. Except I don’t really like blingy guitars, in fact I sold my D55 in favor of my D46, then got rid of my “cheap“ electrics in favor of my bucket list guitars, a Gibson Les Paul Standard and an American Ultra Luxe Fender Stratocaster.
I used to feel many inexpensive guitars was better than one top notch one, and boy was I wrong. One day with the Les Paul and I understood the hype, and had the epiphany, lose the cheap ones and while you are at it, now just get the top of line strat too. That is the best decision I’ve made with guitars, because downsizing has been so liberating. I guess I don’t like having that much money tied up in guitars, so selling off and replacing several with a few was freeing. Plus the ultra luxe is such an amazing guitar. And the LP, dang, sort of feel like I should have just saved and bought one years ago. Instead of thinking the Agile I was lugging around was comparable, and glad I didn’t spend all that money on a Gibson. Foolish to be sure. And hey, visually and sonically they were similar, but fit, finish, playability is light years ahead on the Gibson. Anyways now you can count me in as preferring quality over quantity. So sell the two and get the one if that suits you
7 guitars seems to be my sweet spot, and I was up to 15 only a couple months ago. Making progress, and only two more to unload!